Which Scenario is an Example of Workers’ Compensation Fraud?

example of workers' compensation fraud Workers’ compensation fraud is a serious issue. It involves deceptive practices to obtain benefits unlawfully. Understanding what constitutes fraud helps prevent it and ensures the system works fairly for everyone. Here, we present three scenarios. Two involve fraud, while one does not.

Scenario 1: Faking an Injury

John works at a warehouse. He wants extra time off and some additional cash. John pretends to slip and fall while lifting a box. He fakes a back injury and files a workers’ compensation claim. He exaggerates his pain to doctors and avoids returning to work.

Why is this Fraud?

John’s injury didn’t occur. He misled his employer and the insurance company to receive benefits he didn’t deserve. Faking or exaggerating injuries to collect workers’ compensation is fraudulent.

Scenario 2: Getting Injured on the Job

Susan works in a construction company. One day, she trips over some loose wires and breaks her arm. She immediately reports the injury to her supervisor. Susan receives medical treatment and files a workers’ compensation claim.

Why This Isn’t Fraud

Susan’s injury is legitimate and happened during her work duties. She followed proper procedures by reporting the injury right away. She’s entitled to workers’ compensation benefits to cover her medical expenses and lost wages.

Scenario 3: Working Another Job While on Benefits

Mike is a delivery driver. He injures his knee on the job and starts receiving workers’ compensation benefits. While still claiming he can’t work, Mike takes a job as a cashier at a local store. He doesn’t report this new income to the workers’ compensation board.

Why is this Fraud?

Mike is working another job while claiming he can’t work due to his injury. He’s collecting benefits under pretenses. Not reporting additional income while receiving workers’ compensation is fraudulent.

Impact of Workers’ Compensation Fraud

Fraudulent claims harm everyone. They increase insurance premiums for employers and strain the system, making it harder for genuinely injured workers to get timely help. Employers and employees must be vigilant in recognizing and preventing fraud to maintain a fair and effective workers’ compensation system.

How to Prevent Workers’ Compensation Fraud

Employers should implement safety programs and conduct regular training sessions. Educating employees about the consequences of fraud can deter dishonest claims. Regular audits and monitoring can help detect suspicious activities early. Encouraging a workplace culture of honesty and transparency also plays a significant role.

Reporting Suspected Fraud

If you suspect workers’ compensation fraud, report it immediately. You can contact the Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission’s fraud division. They investigate claims and take action against fraudulent activities. Protecting the integrity of the workers’ compensation system is crucial for ensuring that those who need help receive it without delay.

Workers’ compensation fraud is a critical issue that undermines the system designed to protect injured workers. Recognizing fraudulent activities, such as faking injuries and working while claiming benefits, is essential. Legitimate claims, like Susan’s in Scenario 2, highlight the importance of maintaining an honest and transparent system. By staying informed and vigilant, we can help prevent fraud and ensure that workers’ compensation serves those who truly need it.

If you’d like to discuss your case or have questions about workers’ compensation insurance, contact Shugarman & Mehring at (410) 783-4200 or toll-free at (888) 342-7200.

No Fee, Unless We Win

Call Us Today! 1-410-783-4200 or fill out the form below.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Practice Area

Practice Area

Automobile accidents


A automobile accident can change your life.

Motorcycle and bicycle accidents

Motorcycle and
bicycle accidents

Motorcycle accidents represent a unique area of the law.

Worker's Compensation


Worker’s Compensation in Maryland is a very complicated field to navigate.

Wrongful Death


Facing the loss of a loved is difficult to accept.